Everybody Wants to Build

We keep building at the edges while schools close and storefronts sit empty in the middle. Some thoughts on the unglamorous work of taking care of what we already have, in places we already care about.

Everybody Wants to Build
Photo by Mark König / Unsplash
"Another flaw in the human character is that everybody wants to build and nobody wants to do maintenance."
Eugene Debs Hartke, in Kurt Vonnegut's Hocus Pocus

I grew up in my grandmother's house in Saginaw, Michigan. The house was about 900 square feet, and for a while eight or ten of us lived in it at a time. By the time I came along, Saginaw was a city built for a lot more people than were still around to pay for it. There were vacant lots, crumbling roads, and a tax base that kept shrinking while the region continued to sprawl out. I didn't have words for any of that as a kid. I just knew I wanted to live somewhere that felt alive. I wrote about that a couple of years ago, when I reread Jane Jacobs and realized how much of my career started with that feeling.

I think about Saginaw more than I expected to, now that I live in a place that has never really had to shrink.

There are more than a thousand new homes going up within walking distance of the Elmonica MAX station near my house. Every single one of them comes with a parking space. The building closest to me has two small retail spaces on the ground floor, and I catch myself hoping one of them becomes a café. Some food carts opened around the corner recently, and I was happier about it than I probably should have been. I wrote about why that's so hard in The Myth of the Walkable Corner Store. Planners can zone for the storefront. We can't make anyone open a business in it.

This year I've been sitting on Beaverton School District's long-range facility planning committee, and I've watched the conversation flip almost overnight. Not long ago the question was where to put all the kids. Mountainside High opened at the edge of the district in 2017 with room for 2,200 students. This spring the district closed McKay Elementary because there weren't enough kids left to fill it. I wrote about that in The Big Shrink, and since then Portland has started going through it too. In October the district floated closing as many as 14 schools, and the board meeting got so packed that people pushed past security to get inside. Last week the superintendent recommended closing 10.

I understand that anger in my bones. The house in Saginaw sat six houses away from the line between a good school district and a struggling one, and I've spent my whole life knowing how much that line shaped me. Nobody shows up to a board meeting like that over a facilities spreadsheet. They show up because it's their kid's school, and because they can feel something slipping.

We are very good at building at the edges. A new lane, a new interchange, a new high school out where the farmland used to be. Every one of those made sense to somebody at the time. What we're bad at is the middle. Fixing the sidewalk, or keeping the old high school in good enough shape that it doesn't need to be torn down. Filling in the places we already built so a person could actually walk to something. Nobody holds a ribbon cutting for a new roof, and nobody runs for office promising to repave.

And the people we're building for are changing. There are fewer kids every year. The rest of us are getting older, and someday a lot of us won't be able to drive. When that day comes, a wider road won't help. What will help is a pharmacy down the block, a bench along the way, and frequent bus service.

Portland isn't Saginaw. But I know what it looks like when a place only knows how to grow, and then has to learn the hard way how to take care of what it has. I'd rather we learn it now, while there's still time to do it gently. I want my kids to grow up somewhere that loves its old buildings and its cracked sidewalks and that little storefront under the apartments. I want them to have somewhere to walk to.